
Review: ‘Long Lost First Play’ at Tavern has worthy ideas but still feels lost
Scholars will tell you that Shakespeare’s first work was likely either Titus Andronicus or one of the Henry VI plays. But Reed Martin and Austin Tichenor, the scribes of William Shakespeare’s Long Lost First Play (abridged), will tell you it was an overstuffed Frankenstein’s monster of every play he would go on to write. If you’re curious about their theory, the play runs through August 17 at the Shakespeare Tavern and is a mixed bag of amusing inventions, hit-or-miss jokes and Shakespearean deep cuts.
The central premise is that a group of Shakespearean actors (played by Mary Ruth Ralston, Nick Faircloth and J.L. Reed) discovers a lost Shakespeare manuscript buried in a Trader Joe’s parking lot. Quickly surmising that their discovery is the first play Shakespeare ever wrote, they decide to perform it in all its glory (after being laughed out of the Folger Shakespeare Library, that is).
The play itself turns out to be a 100-hour amalgamation of all of Shakespeare’s other works, which we are to assume he later broke up into the 39+ plays we have now. Setting aside the inanity of this idea (the authenticity of which Martin and Tichenor leave up in the air), it comes off as an excuse to do a retooled version of The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abridged) but with less of that show’s propulsive humor.

The first act of William Shakespeare’s Long Lost First Play is a slog, introducing some interesting or funny bits but often getting bogged down in metatheatrics. The concept of the play-within-a-play is actually quite interesting, featuring characters from Shakespeare’s other plays thrown together by the machinations of Puck (from A Midsummer Night’s Dream) and Ariel (from The Tempest). However, the show frequently breaks from the play-within-a-play to have the actors disagree on how certain characters should be played or what scenes should be cut. While some of these moments are amusing, they are disruptive to the pacing and lack the narrative weight needed to justify their inclusion.
Things pick up considerably in the second act as the play discards metatheatrics in favor of zeroing in on the play-within-a-play, bringing the narrative cohesion and comedic momentum that the first act lacks. Characters interact in amusing and organic ways, and the inventiveness of the playwrights is allowed to fully shine. Standout moments include Kate from Taming of the Shrew and Beatrice from Much Ado About Nothing teaching Juliet how to curse out men; anything involving the Weird Sisters; and a clever inversion of the famous stage direction “exit pursued by a bear.” The playwrights even manage to tie the far-fetched premise together in a somewhat satisfying way.

The first act is stymied by some uninteresting staging, relying on jokes that are either immediately contrived or start out funny and outstay their welcome. Director Andrew Houchins creates dynamic moments in the second act, giving the impression that he wanted the back half to feel like a significant escalation – but by that point, it feels too late.
While it is strange to say that I would recommend the second act of a play while not recommending the whole production, that is nonetheless the case here. The play ends on an undeniably strong note, but one cannot help but feel the payoff isn’t worth sitting through the first act.
None of the faults of the script or direction fall on the actors, however, who are all giving committed and chameleonic performances. They take on the lion’s task of performing well over a dozen roles with only three actors, and they do it with skill and aplomb. Most of the play’s best moments come from their performances.
William Shakespeare’s Long Lost First Play is not a play without its virtues, but with a first act that feels split between a funny academic SNL skit and a halfhearted Noises Off, the second act has to work too hard to balance things out. The idea of mashing a bunch of Shakespearean characters together is enticing and yields fun results, but making the idea fit within the framework of “Shakespeare’s first play” feels like cramming a square peg into a round hole. While this piece may give the audience a few laughs, it ends up feeling less than the sum of its parts.
Where & When
William Shakespeare’s Long Lost First Play (abridged) is at The Shakespeare Tavern Playhouse through August 17. Tickets start at $36 and depend on seating.
499 Peachtree St. NE.
::

Luke Evans is an Atlanta-based writer, critic and dramaturg. He covers theater for ArtsATL and Broadway World Atlanta and has worked with theaters such as the Alliance, Actor’s Express, Out Front Theatre and Woodstock Arts. He’s a graduate of Oglethorpe University, where he earned his bachelor’s degree, and the University of Houston, where he earned his master’s.
STAY UP TO DATE ON ALL THINGS ArtsATL
Subscribe to our free weekly e-newsletter.




