
Review: ‘Beautiful’ at City Springs stages Carole King story with solid cast and songbook
Despite her reputation as a recording legend, Carole King started off predominantly as a songwriter, only prompted to sing later by friends and colleagues. The Tony Award-winning Beautiful: The Carole King Musical — closing the seventh season for City Springs Theatre Company — explores the artist’s nonlinear path and the power she eventually finds in herself. Running through May 18 at the Byers Theatre of the Sandy Springs Performing Arts Center, Beautiful is a mostly satisfying production, helped immensely by its score and cast.
In local actor Megan K. Hill, the musical has a performer who convincingly plays Carole for 15 years of her career and knows how to pounce on the show’s songbook. The musical opens at Carnegie Hall in 1971, where Carole sings one of her big hits, “So Far Away.” The show then tracks the long road it took for her to get to that point, flashing back to the future musical superstar as a 16-year-old trying to get permission from her mother Genie (Courtenay Collins) to travel to New York and try to sell her music. She does go and meets Don Kirshner (Jordan Sam Rich), who likes her songs and puts her career on track.

At college, Carole meets lyricist Gerry Goffin (Nick Walker Jones). They begin a professional relationship and soon are writing hit songs for other artists such as the Drifters and the Shirelles. Carole also becomes friends with lyricist Cynthia Weil (Lily Kaufmann) and composer Barry Mann (Haden Rider), whose office is next door. Those two are trying to make names for themselves in the industry as well, and the group supports one another.
This production is directed by Shane Delancey, who also helmed Jersey Boys and Monty Python’s Spamalot at the company. One of the big surprises (for those seeing the production for the first time or not overly familiar with Carole’s early days) is just how many famous songs she wrote or co-wrote in the ’60s. As a jukebox musical, the production is top-heavy with many of those numbers, most of which are staged energetically. The Drifters (Jerrell Melton III, Cedric J. Paige, Charles Pruitt and Zac Pritts) and the Shirelles (Kyla Boling, Mionne Destiny, Alexandria Joy, Shena Renee) have some terrific numbers, and “Up on the Roof” is a particular standout.
Yet the first act has some issues. I’ve seen the musical three times now (including two touring versions), and I’m always left with the same impression overall — the show is much better musically than it is digging deep into who Carole really was. Douglas McGrath’s book doesn’t get into high gear until the second hour or so.
At times, too, it seems that Carole is an ensemble member of her own show. A lot of Act I features the characters of Cynthia and Barry. No offense to them or the performers bringing them to life here, but Carole deserves to be more the central figure.
The musical is so much sharper when it’s about Carole finding her voice — literally — and her own strength than checking Carole off Jukebox Musical 101 boxes. Structurally, the first hour can feel monotonous, with characters referencing a number and then performers coming out to sing it. Delancey can’t always enliven that, either.

The most satisfying moment in Delancey’s production is when Carole winds up at a nightclub with Cynthia and Barry. She’s been asked to sing in front of a crowd before and has initially declined, but tonight she is convinced to introduce her new song, “It’s Too Late.” It’s a great moment. Used to writing for others, she slowly learns that she can be center stage. From there, the rest of the show is fully alive, including a moment where Carole — again reluctantly– records “You Make Me Feel Like a Natural Woman.”
Hill finds a lot of dimensions in her portrayal of Carole, starting off starry-eyed as she moves to New York. She becomes a different person over the years as she balances her place in the industry and her own changing personal life.
Just as effective is Jones in a role that can be a little one-dimensional. The most intriguing relationship in the musical is that between Carole and Gerry, whose infidelities threaten their marriage. Eventually, when things do not work out with her husband, Carole and her two kids uproot and move to Los Angeles, where she records “Tapestry” and becomes a musical legend.
Technically, there’s not much to complain about with this production. Chase Anderson leads 12 others as part of the company’s orchestra and more than 24 numbers are solidly staged. Delancey’s ensemble, with both Broadway actors and local ones, is tight and Jordan Pretorius’ choreography throughout is dynamic. Alejo Vietti’s period-appropriate costumes from the original 2014 Broadway run also enhance the production.
Beautiful isn’t the definitive Carole King show, but this production is certainly well-staged and entertaining. It should be a popular ticket.
Where & When
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, staged by City Springs Theatre Company, is at the Byers Theatre at Sandy Springs Performing Arts Center through May 18. Tickets start around $60.
1 Galambos Way, Sandy Springs.
::

Jim Farmer is the recipient of the 2022 National Arts and Entertainment Journalism Award for Best Theatre Feature and a nominee for Online Journalist of the Year. A member of five national critics’ organizations, he covers theater and film for ArtsATL. A graduate of the University of Georgia, he has written about the arts for 30-plus years. Jim is the festival director of Out on Film, Atlanta’s LGBTQ film festival, and lives in Avondale Estates with his husband, Craig.
STAY UP TO DATE ON ALL THINGS ArtsATL
Subscribe to our free weekly e-newsletter.




